Coordinating Units, Part 2

This post continues my September 20, 2016 post, “Coordinating Units: A Brief Introduction”.

Last time, I introduced a problem to illustrate the basic differences between additive reasoning and multiplicative reasoning used to solve a problem. I also defined levels of units and what it means to “coordinate units”.  In addition, I said that “in activity” means that a level can only be accessed while working on the problem and perhaps using other physical aids. This time, I want to extend the problem to talk about students working at even higher cognitive levels…

A student can assimilate with 2 levels in activity, with 2 levels, with 3 levels in activity, with 3 levels, etc. I will give an example to show the difference between assimilating with 3 levels and assimilating with 3 levels in activity. Let’s extend the vacation problem as follows:

I am away for three weeks. At the end of the three weeks, I decide to stay away for five more weeks. How many total days is that?

Assimilating with 3 levels in activity, the student could reason this way:

3 weeks x 7 days/week = 21 days

5 weeks x 7 days/week = 35 days

21 days + 35 days = 56 days

But if you ask this student how many weeks, that would be a new problem to solve, because the student wouldn’t be able to hold all the information.

Assimilating with 3 levels, the students could reason this way:

3 weeks and 5 weeks are two “like composite units”, so they can be added:

3 weeks + 5 weeks is 8 weeks.

Then, 8 weeks x 7 days/week = 56 days

This student can operate on a week as a unit, as well as a day as a unit. The more levels that a student can assimilate with, the more problem solving power that student brings into the situation.Following is a problem for you to consider. Think about how students assimilating with 1, 2, or 3 levels might approach this problem:

In a classroom, there are six desks in each of four rows. The teacher wants to add seats until there are 36 in the class. How many more rows will be added?

Share

Leave a reply