The term composite unit is important in understanding how children come to know math. When a student builds math concepts with a composite unit as part of the foundation, there is a real perceivable difference in what the student can do compared to students who learn math simply as a set of procedures.
One of the early uses of composite units for students is in doing addition and subtraction. Give a student the basic problem: 22 – 17 = __. “School math” would have a procedure or algorithm utilizing borrowing. I use the term “school math” to describe what happens in a traditional classroom where a procedure is initiated by adult understanding rather than by the student’s mathematics. The student could follow the procedure and even get the correct answer, without really understanding what happened or why. With an understanding of composites, the student would understand that 17 is contained in 22, and the goal is to find the remaining part. The student could then just count from 17 up to 22, monitoring the count to get the answer. While this may sound more primitive, a better, deeper understanding will be the pay off in the long run. The important thing to know is that this understanding of counting-on cannot be taught. The procedure of counting-on can be taught, but it must be the initiative of the student for it to have meaning.
My team has been working on understanding the composite units for multiplication, using what we refer to as towers tasks. Multiplication is the coordination of two composite units so that one of the composite units is distributed over the elements of the other composite unit. The towers tasks, created by Ron Tzur and others, are designed to help students learn this in the context of a classroom activity. We have confirmed that students utilizing the towers tasks come to have a clearer understanding of what they are doing by multiplying numbers rather than students who are just memorizing the multiplication table.
The next step for students would be to develop fractions based on fractional composite units. It would follow naturally from what has already been learned and allow for more understanding than the empty procedures that have become the basis of “school mathematics,” especially with fractions. For example, take a fraction like 1/5, and treat it as a unit, the way we treat 1. In “school math,” 1/5 is usually thought of as 1 part in 5, and is not usually treated as a unit to count or measure. The traditional approach is limited, in that it doesn’t allow students to learn to work with fractions in the same ways that they learn to work with whole numbers.
Starting with a fraction as a composite unit, other ideas naturally fall into place, like counting and adding. For example, how many 1/5’s are contained in 3? By the traditional “school math” method, a student would be taught to divide 3 by 1/5, which involves the division algorithm. Students might get a better grounding by simply counting by 1/5’s up to 3.
Following learning fractions, with just a change in the composite unit, the students can move on to the next step. By calling x (an unknown quantity) the composite unit, and having available all the same computing schemes and operations, Algebra is a natural and understandable development.
Can you think back to learning math in school? Was there ever anything that didn’t seem to make sense, yet you could do the procedure well enough to solve the problems?
Steffe, L. P. (1992). Schemes of action and operation involving composite units. Learning and Individual Differences, 4(3), 259–309.
Tzur, R., Johnson, H., McClintock, E., Xin, Y. P., Si, L., Woodward, C. H., & Jin, X. (2013). Distinguishing schemes and tasks in children’s development of multiplicative reasoning. PNA, 7(3), 85–101.
As we come to the end of another school year, our team here at the AIMS Center has been spending time reflecting on the past year of learning from students. We were asked the question, “If you could go back into the classroom, what would you do differently in regards to your math instruction?” I… Continue Reading
After one month as a missionary in Argentina I was ready to raise the dead. Or at least that is what the woman at the door must have thought. Let me explain. As we were proselyting door to door, it was my turn to talk to whoever answered the door. A woman happened to answer… Continue Reading
My 4-year-old grandson and I have been spending a lot of time together. Without him realizing, we have been doing and talking more mathematics around the house. The other day I was rebuilding a gate and while I was measuring a board to cut, he picked up the tape measure wanting to help out. So… Continue Reading
Two experiences this month have opened my eyes to the value of the research we are learning about at the AIMS Center. One involves my 5th grade daughter Neva, and the other was a conversation with a second grade student I have been working with. Neva says she doesn’t like math, but she has been… Continue Reading
Whew!!! You’re almost there! This is the time of year that things get a little crazy in your classroom but you are also winding down the school year. It’s time to reflect on where your students are and just how much they have grown this past school year. It is also the time to begin… Continue Reading
We recently attended the annual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, NCTM. This year’s conference was in San Antonio, Texas. We were mostly a group of research associates from the AIMS Center. The size of the conference (over 7000 attendees) and the wide range of presentation topics worked together to create a… Continue Reading
You have probably all heard the statement, “If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.” Generally this statement is used to convince ourselves that we can trust what we see, or that we can make sense of our world by gathering evidence… Continue Reading
Yesterday, my daughter called me and told me there was a horrible scratching sound coming from her car. It was her brake pads. I have replaced brake pads on lots of cars, but not hers. The bolts came off easily and the pads came out without much effort and so I thought everything was going… Continue Reading
A few posts ago (December 13, 2016 and February 21, 2017), I discussed the importance of skip counting with meaning. If you are teaching particular grade levels, you may have students who skip count to solve problems already. So, how can we tell if skip counting is meaningful to them? Often times, a student will… Continue Reading