“Sixteen!” My grandson shouts, sitting on the floor smiling, fingers extended. We had been playing with his toy cars. He counted out nine, gave them to me, and I put them behind me out of his sight. He then counted out seven more, gave them to me also, and I hid them under a nearby pillow. I asked him how many cars I had together. He counted to nine, extending fingers, stopping when he had said nine. He then pulled back his fingers and continued counting 10, 11, …,16, while extending seven of his fingers for a second time. This was new for him and he was excited. I have seen him grow in his efficiency using fingers. The fact is, fingers are tools children use in mathematics. (1) There is an ever-increasing wealth of information pointing to the importance of finger usage by young children in mathematics. Some teachers think that finger usage for students is an indicator of immaturity, and they encourage students to abandon the practice as early as possible.
Teachers know kids use their fingers in various ways but may not know what the differences are, what they mean, or how to use what they see to help students. The complexity and variations of finger usage are often missed. The earliest use of fingers for mathematical purposes is usually the counting of fingers. This is seen when a child is asked: “What is 5 and 2?” We’ll see them pop up five fingers, on one hand, a two on the other, and then count all the extended fingers to determine a total. (2) There are variations in this type of usage. (3) But it can’t stop there. (4) The Common Core Progression documents affirm this by stating, “Using fingers is not a concern unless it remains at the first level of direct modeling in later grades.”
One advancement in a child’s use of fingers is their use for monitoring. Monitoring means the child uses their fingers to keep track of their counting. Often, finger patterns become the tool used to monitor counting. A child counting-on may continue their counting five more counts by filling a finger pattern for five to signal an end to their counting. (5) These same finger patterns also assist children to monitor counting backward to determine when to stop in situations involving takeaway. (6) In “change unknown” situations, a child may use their fingers to keep track of the counts, such as from 12 to 19, recognizing the finger pattern for seven upon the completion of the counting activity and realizing the finger pattern represents the unknown addend in the problem.
Continued development of finger usage is seen in their use of fingers when counting composites. In one situation we use children build towers with cubes and then those towers are hidden. For example, five towers with three cubes in each tower. The teacher can then ask for the total number of cubes. We saw children develop the ability to count the groups of three with fingers on one hand while keeping count of the number of towers on the other hand. (7) Children’s finger usage is even seen in our early work with fractions.(8) The important point is that the use of fingers should grow along with the sophistication of children’s mathematics. I will continue to encourage my grandson to use his fingers in ways that reflect the growing sophistication of his mathematical thinking and in the process, I hope to see many more of his smiles and his enthusiasm.
For further reading about finger usage:
- “Handy Little Fingers as Counters”, Wilma Hashimoto October 30, 2017
- “Finger Pattern Adding Schemes: Sums Less Than Ten”, Beverly Ford, May 24, 2017
- “Fingers As Math Tools – Part 2 Let’s Get Tapping”, Elin Anderson, February 15, 2017
- “Counting and Fingers”, Grace Florez, May 16, 2018
- “Mathematics of Grace: Figurative Mental Material”, Beverly Ford, April 5, 2017.
- “Takeaways from Subtraction Part 2: Take Away or Not to Take Away” David Pearce, January 30, 2018.
- “What Every Student Needs to Know for Multiplication (Part 1)”, Elin Anderson, October 31, 2017.
- “Composite Units and Fractions”, Brook Lewis, March 28, 2017.
Progressions for the Common Core, State Standards in Mathematics (draft), The Common Core Standards Writing Team, 29 May 2011.
My previous blog post, “Sharing can be Rigorous Work!”, I shared that part of the work we have been doing in the last few months investigates how students develop fractional reasoning based on the work of Dr. Les Steffe. When I taught 2nd grade under the previous California Standards it included exposure to fractions where… Continue Reading
“A snake!” “A tree!” “A spear!” All are descriptions of the same item. Do you know what it is? Have you read Ed Young’s children’s story about the adventures of seven blind mice? Adapted from an old Indian fable about several sojourners and an elephant, Young crafts a wonderfully simple and elegant tale of how… Continue Reading
How much of a difference makes a difference? When my dad taught us to play golf he showed us how being out of alignment by a few inches at the ball would result in being off by 20 yards at the place the ball was going. In teaching, we make decisions about materials we use,… Continue Reading
I am always impressed with the passion teachers have for their work. Education in general, and teachers specifically, have received a lot of negative press. The story line seems to be that the system is broken and failing our kids, so let’s throw those bums out. But if you listen to teachers talk about their… Continue Reading
As the school year winds down, at the AIMS Center we too are wrapping up our work with students. The tasks we asked second and third graders to engage in this year had students working with various manipulatives (cubes, blocks, bags, strips, etc). This made me think about Math Practice 5: Use appropriate tools strategically.… Continue Reading
Teaching middle school I often had students who still used their fingers to find the difference between 12 and 7. They would start with 7 and then count 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 while putting up fingers each time they would say a number. When we worked with integers and subtraction the idea that positive… Continue Reading
I want to tell you about a boy that we call Greg. If you’re a teacher, you’ve likely had a Greg in your class before. He’s the one that fascinates you because he thinks so deeply, is so curious, and seems to already know everything you’re trying to “teach” him. He’s also the one that… Continue Reading
I’m coming up on the two year anniversary at my current job and I’ve been reflecting on how my thinking has changed over this time. Before this job, I felt I had a good grasp on teaching math. I had just spent 20 years teaching junior high math. I faced down the torch and pitchfork… Continue Reading
In my last blog post I wrote about how the sharing activity we are engaging second and third grade students with, although seemingly very simple, is actually very rigorous. In my observations I have been amused by how fascinated and excited the students are to be doing something where they are allowed to use glue… Continue Reading